Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@trusktr
Last active May 25, 2020 06:48
Show Gist options
  • Save trusktr/8c515f7bd7436e09a4baa7a63cd7cc37 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Save trusktr/8c515f7bd7436e09a4baa7a63cd7cc37 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Multiple Inheritance Implementation #2 - Copying classes and combining them into a single prototype chain. Fails miserably due to static `super` and use of `eval`, among other problems.
function multiple(...classes) {
// If more than one class extends from a native class, we may need to throw
// an error, since we can't mix native prototypes; We won't throw if the
// native prototypes of one class or in the same chain as the native
// prototypes in the others. For example, if one class extends from Array
// and another from Event, we'll throw an error because we can't put the
// Array prototype before the Event prototype or vice versa
// (`Array.prototype` and `Event.prototype` are `{enumerable:false,
// writable:false, configurable:false}`, so we can't change the __proto__ of
// those native prototypes, nor can we copy the native prototypes in order
// to mix the copies). However, if one class extends (for example) the
// AudioProcessingEvent (which extends Event) and another class extends
// Event, then we don't need to throw an error because we can just re-use
// the AudioProcessingEvent class prototype which already contains the Event
// class prototype. Lastly and for example, if one class extends Array and
// another extends AudioProcessingEvent as in the previous example, throw an
// error because we can't mix the native prototypes.
//
// NOTE, if this check passes and if the classes being mixed are all
// classes that don't extend any native classes, then the
// commonLeafmostNativeProto will simply be Object.prototype.
let commonLeafmostNativeProto = findCommonLeafmostPrototype(...classes)
console.log('commonLeafmostNativeProto:', commonLeafmostNativeProto)
if ( ! commonLeafmostNativeProto ) {
throw new Error(`
The provided classes cannot be mixed because they contain more than
one native prototype chain, and it's simply not possible to mix
them. For a more in-depth explanation, see: http://.....
`)
}
// Duplicate each non-native prototype chain, attach them together, and
// finally attach the chain to the commonLeafmostNativeProto (TODO in the
// future we want to cache prototype chains and re-use them, instead of just
// creating a new chain each time).
//
// TODO: Associate with each cloned prototype a clone of the constructor.
// Use eval to make `super` work.
//
// TODO: Set @@hasInstance of the original classes so instanceof works.
let currentClonedProto = null
let lastClonedProto = null
let composedProtoChain = null
classes.forEach((currentClass, index) => {
let currentProtoOfCurrentClass = currentClass.prototype
// for each prototype of the currentClass
while (true) {
// If we've reached a native class, break the loop for the current
// class so we can move to the next class and clone the next chain.
//
// This happens in the last iteration of the do..while loop, once
// we've reached the first native prototype.
if (isNativeMethod(currentProtoOfCurrentClass.constructor)) {
// If we're on the last class and at the end of that class'
// chain (on the first native prototype) then attach the
// commonLeafmostNativeProto.
if (index === classes.length-1 && lastClonedProto) {
Object.setPrototypeOf(lastClonedProto, commonLeafmostNativeProto)
}
break
}
else {
// CONTINUE: find methods on currentProtoOfCurrentClass that use
// `super`, get the string value, convert to object initiliazer
// form, then eval. For example:
currentClonedProto = cloneByDescriptor(currentProtoOfCurrentClass)
console.log('current cloned proto:', currentClonedProto)
// If we haven't saved the leafmost prototype of the composed
// chain (i.e. the first prototype to be cloned), save it.
if (!composedProtoChain) {
composedProtoChain = currentClonedProto
console.log('proto chain tail:', composedProtoChain)
}
if (lastClonedProto) {
Object.setPrototypeOf(lastClonedProto, currentClonedProto)
}
lastClonedProto = currentClonedProto
currentProtoOfCurrentClass = Object.getPrototypeOf(currentProtoOfCurrentClass)
}
}
})
// return the composed class.
console.log(' --- The final class!!', composedProtoChain.constructor)
return composedProtoChain.constructor
}
// TODO: Also copy Symbol properties.
function cloneByDescriptor(objectToClone) {
let newObj = null
let methodsBody = ''
const props = Object.getOwnPropertyNames(objectToClone)
// copy the methods with proper `[[HomeObject]]`s
for (let prop of props) {
const descriptor = Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(objectToClone, prop)
// If we have a function, append it's method-version to the methodsBody
// for later when we use eval to set [[HomeObject]] of the methods
// properly.
//
// TODO: handle multiple `super()` calls in `constructor()` methods. It
// isn't likely, so skipping for now.
//
// TODO: handle super calls in getters/setters. It isn't likely, so
// skipping for now. For now, those are copied in the next for loop
// after we use eval in this loop.
if (descriptor.value && typeof descriptor.value == 'function') {
let methodString = descriptor.value.toString()
// Remove "function <name>" from the method string to replace it
// with "<prop>". F.e., if `prop === "bar"`, then `function blah() {}`
// will be converted to `bar() {}`.
//
// TODO check the regex works.
// const funcNameRegex= r`\s*function\s*(?:${r.identifier}\s*)?`
// methodString = methodString.replace(funcNameRegex, prop)
// If `prop` is "constructor", then replace `super(...)` with
// `super.constructor(...)`. We need to do this so that we can wrap
// the constructor in a new constructor that can be called with new
// (because otherwise object initializer methods cannot be used with
// `new`).
if (prop == 'constructor') {
const superRegex = r`super\s*\((.*?)\)`
const match = superRegex.exec(methodString)
if (match) {
// capture group 1 contains the arguments to the super() call.
const args = match[1]
methodString = methodString.replace(match[0], `super.constructor(${args})`)
}
}
// methodsBody += `${methodString},\n`
methodsBody += `${prop}: ${methodString},\n`
}
}
// Here we use eval so that we can assign all the copied methods at once and
// so that they will have the expected `[[HomeObject]]` so that super calls
// work.
eval(`
newObj = {
${methodsBody}
}
`)
// now copy the non-methods.
for (let prop of props) {
const descriptor = Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(objectToClone, prop)
if (! (descriptor.value && typeof descriptor.value == 'function')) {
Object.defineProperty(newObj, prop, descriptor)
}
}
// Wrap the constructor in a new constructor that can be called with `new`
// (because otherwise object initializer methods cannot be used with `new`).
// let wrappedCtor = newObj.constructor
// newObj.constructor = function() {
// console.log(' **** constructor wrapper **** ', wrappedCtor)
// wrappedCtor.call(this)
// }
newObj.constructor.prototype = newObj
return newObj
}
/**
* Checks if the supplied method is a native method belonging
* to the JS environment. If you suspect Object.prototype.toString or
* Function.prototype.toString has been overridden, supply a vanilla context
* from which to use the native toString methods.
*
* Some code borrowed from
* https://gist.github.com/jdalton/5e34d890105aca44399f#file-isnative-js-L50
*
* @param {type} method The method to check.
* @param {type} context The context who's toString methods will be taken from.
* If one isn't provided, defaults to the current global context (`window` in
* browsers, `global` in Node.js), but it is highly recommended to supply one as
* this also guards against methods that are created with `.bind()` which seem
* to be native although they are not, and so providing a vanilla context
* ensures that there are no bound methods in the context so that we don't get
* faked out.
* @returns {GlobalContext} Return a plain unmodified `window` object in
* browsers, and a plain unmodified `global` object in Node.js.
*/
function isNativeMethod(method, context) {
const ctx = context || getCurrentGlobalContext()
// Used to resolve the internal `[[Class]]` of values.
const toString = ctx.Object.prototype.toString
// Used to resolve the decompiled source of functions.
const fnToString = ctx.Function.prototype.toString
// Used to detect host constructors (Safari > 4; really typed array specific).
const reHostCtor = /^\[object .+?Constructor\]$/
// Compile a regexp using a common native method as a template.
// We chose `Object#toString` because there's a good chance it is not being mucked with.
const reNative = ctx.RegExp('^' +
// Coerce `Object#toString` to a string.
ctx.String(toString)
// Escape any special regexp characters.
.replace(/[.*+?^${}()|[\]\/\\]/g, '\\$&')
// Replace mentions of `toString` with `.*?` to keep the template generic.
// Replace thing like `for ...` to support environments, like Rhino, which add extra
// info such as method arity.
.replace(/toString|(function).*?(?=\\\()| for .+?(?=\\\])/g, '$1.*?') + '$'
)
const type = typeof method
return type == 'function'
// Use `Function#toString` to bypass the method's own `toString` method
// and avoid being faked out.
? reNative.test(fnToString.call(method))
// Fallback to a host object check because some environments will represent
// things like typed arrays as DOM methods which may not conform to the
// normal native pattern.
: (method && type == 'object' && reHostCtor.test(toString.call(method))) || false
}
/**
* getCurrentGlobalContext - Get the current global object.
*
* @returns {GlobalContext} The current global object (`window` in browsers, `global` in Node.js).
*/
function getCurrentGlobalContext() {
let ctx = null
// XXX is there a better check to perform?
if (typeof window == 'object') ctx = window // browsers
else if (typeof global == 'object') ctx = global // Node.js
return ctx
}
function getVanillaContext() {
let context = getCurrentGlobalContext()
// in browser environments
if (typeof window != 'undefined') {
let iframe = document.createElement("iframe")
iframe.height = 0
iframe.width = 0
document.body.appendChild(iframe)
context = iframe.contentWindow
}
// in Node.js environments
else if (typeof global != 'undefined') {
// TODO ...
}
return context
}
function destroyVanillaContext(ctx) {
}
function findCommonLeafmostPrototype(...classes) {
// cache for the following checks. If afterwords we have more than one
// leafmost native prototype, it means we have a branch, and we cannot mix
// the classes.
const cache = new Set
// get all the leafmost native classes, and if we have only one, then we're
// good.
classes.forEach((ctor, index) => {
const tmpFunc = function() {}
const currentLeafmostNativePrototype = getLeafmostNativePrototype(ctor)
// Add the first native prototype to the cache by default.
if (index == 0) cache.add(currentLeafmostNativePrototype)
// if the any of the currently cached leafmost native prototypes contain the current
// leafmost native prototype, we don't need to cache it.
const protosToRemoveFromCache = new Set
const protosToAddToCache = new Set
for (let cachedProto of cache) {
// break if already cached
if (cachedProto === currentLeafmostNativePrototype) break
// break if cachedProto already contains the current
// currentLeafmostNativePrototype of the outter loop in its chain
//
// HACK: Use tmpFunc prototype to perform the following instanceof
// check, since the right hand side of instanceof must be a function.
tmpFunc.prototype = currentLeafmostNativePrototype
if (cachedProto instanceof tmpFunc) break
// Perform the reverse check, maybe the current proto contains the
// cached proto
//
// similar HACK here as the previous one.
tmpFunc.prototype = cachedProto
if (currentLeafmostNativePrototype instanceof tmpFunc) {
// mark the cachedProto for removal after the loop is done.
protosToRemoveFromCache.add(cachedProto)
// and mark the currentLeafmostNativePrototype for addition to
// the cache because it contains the current cachedProto in its
// chain.
protosToAddToCache.add(currentLeafmostNativePrototype)
}
// Otherwise we have a new leafmost native prototype
else {
// mark the currentLeafmostNativePrototype for addition to the
// cache because it doesn't contain the cachedProto, nor does
// the cachedProto contain it.
protosToAddToCache.add(currentLeafmostNativePrototype)
// NOTE, we could possibly just return false here and terminate
// the function, since we've satisfied the false requirement.
}
}
for (let proto of protosToRemoveFromCache) cache.delete(proto)
protosToRemoveFromCache.clear()
for (let proto of protosToAddToCache) cache.add(proto)
protosToAddToCache.clear()
})
// If we have more than one native prototype in the cache, it means we found
// more than one leafmost native prototype, which means we cannot mix the
// given classes as expected, so return false.
if (cache.size != 1) return false
// return the first and only value (if all the above went well)
return cache.values().next().value
}
/**
* Given a class constructor, traverses up the class' prototype chain to find
* the first native prototype (one defined by the JS environment, not by JS
* code).
*
* @param {type} ctor The class constructor from which to begin the search.
* @returns {Object} The leafmost prototype.
*/
function getLeafmostNativePrototype(ctor) {
let result = null
if (!ctor) return result
let currentProto = ctor.prototype
while (currentProto) {
let currentCtor = currentProto.constructor
if (isNativeMethod(currentCtor)) {
result = currentProto
break
}
currentProto = Object.getPrototypeOf(currentProto)
}
return result
}
export { multiple as default }
class One {
constructor(options) {
console.log('One constructor')
console.log(super.constructor)
this.one = options.one
}
foo() {console.log('foo')}
}
class Two {
constructor(options) {
console.log('Two constructor')
console.log(super.constructor)
this.two = options.two
}
bar() {console.log('bar')}
}
class Three extends Two {
constructor(options) {
super(options)
console.log('Three constructor')
console.log(super.constructor)
this.three = options.three
}
baz() {console.log('baz')}
}
class FooBar extends multiple(Three, One) {
constructor(options) {
console.log('FooBar constructor')
super(options)
console.log(super.constructor)
}
yeah() {console.log('yeah')}
}
let f = new FooBar({
one: 1,
two: 2,
three: 3,
})
console.log('f?', f)
// this shows that the modifications to `this` by each constructor worked:
console.log(f.one, f.two, f.three) // logs "1 2 3"
// all methods work:
f.foo()
f.bar()
f.baz()
f.yeah()
console.log(' --------------------------------- ran tests')
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment